Purgatory

Sam Shepard

Sheriff Forrest / Wild Bill Hickock

Eric Roberts

Blackjack Britton

Randy Quaid

Doc Woods / Doc Holliday

Peter Stormare

Cavin Guthrie

Brad Rowe

Leon 'Sonny' Miller

Donnie Wahlberg

Deputy Glen / Billy the Kid

JD Souther

Brooks / Jesse James

Amelia Heinle

Rose / Betty McCullough

Shannon Kenny

Dolly Sloan / Ivy

John Dennis Johnston

Lamb / 'Lefty' Slade

Saginaw Grant

Gatekeeper

Richard Edson

Euripides

Gregory Scott Cummins

Knox

John Diehl

Badger

R.G. Armstrong

Coachman

Les Lannom

Bartender

Michael Shaner

Jacinto

Phil Hawn

Inhabitant of Refuge (uncredited)