Kifferwahn

Kristen Bell

Mary Lane

Christian Campbell

Jimmy Harper

Neve Campbell

Miss Poppy

Alan Cumming

Lecturer / Goat-Man / FDR

Ana Gasteyer

Mae Coleman

John Kassir

Ralph Wiley / Uncle Sam

Amy Spanger

Sally DeBains / Statue of Liberty

Christine Lakin

Joan of Arc / Female Dancer

Lynda Boyd

Mrs. Deirdre Greevey

Robert Torti

Jesus

Steven Weber

Jack Stone / George Washington

Kevin McNulty

Mayor Harris MacDonald

Stephen E. Miller

Mr. Paul Kochinski

Robert Clarke

Principal Poindexter Short

Harry S. Murphy

Warden Harrah

Ruth Nichol

Mrs. Roxanne MacDonald

Kristie Marsden

Female Dancer

Alexz Johnson

The Arc-ettes / Vocal Ensemble

Britt Irvin

The Arc-ettes

Patti Allan

Jimmy's Mom